Also check PyQt version for qtutils.version_check()

With an older PyQt built against a newer Qt, we still don't have its features
available.

This also drops support for exact=True with compiled=True as the semantics for
that are unclear, and it's not used.

qutebrowser/utils/qtutils.py

@@ -33,7 +33,8 @@ import contextlib
 
 import pkg_resources
 from PyQt5.QtCore import (qVersion, QEventLoop, QDataStream, QByteArray,
-                          QIODevice, QSaveFile, QT_VERSION_STR)
+                          QIODevice, QSaveFile, QT_VERSION_STR,
+                          PYQT_VERSION_STR)
 try:
     from PyQt5.QtWebKit import qWebKitVersion
 except ImportError:  # pragma: no cover
@@ -82,12 +83,18 @@ def version_check(version, exact=False, compiled=True):
     # Catch code using the old API for this
     assert exact not in [operator.gt, operator.lt, operator.ge, operator.le,
                          operator.eq], exact
+    if compiled and exact:
+        raise ValueError("Can't use compiled=True with exact=True!")
+
     parsed = pkg_resources.parse_version(version)
     op = operator.eq if exact else operator.ge
     result = op(pkg_resources.parse_version(qVersion()), parsed)
     if compiled and result:
-        # v1 ==/>= parsed, now check if v2 ==/>= parsed too.
+        # qVersion() ==/>= parsed, now check if QT_VERSION_STR ==/>= parsed.
         result = op(pkg_resources.parse_version(QT_VERSION_STR), parsed)
+    if compiled and result:
+        # FInally, check PYQT_VERSION_STR as well.
+        result = op(pkg_resources.parse_version(PYQT_VERSION_STR), parsed)
     return result
 
 

tests/end2end/conftest.py

@@ -84,10 +84,11 @@ def _get_version_tag(tag):
     if package == 'qt':
         op = match.group('operator')
         do_skip = {
-            '==': not qtutils.version_check(version, exact=True),
+            '==': not qtutils.version_check(version, exact=True,
+                                            compiled=False),
             '>=': not qtutils.version_check(version),
             '<': qtutils.version_check(version),
-            '!=': qtutils.version_check(version, exact=True),
+            '!=': qtutils.version_check(version, exact=True, compiled=False),
         }
         return pytest.mark.skipif(do_skip[op], reason='Needs ' + tag)
     elif package == 'pyqt':

tests/unit/utils/test_qtutils.py

@@ -39,34 +39,36 @@ from qutebrowser.utils import qtutils, utils
 import overflow_test_cases
 
 
-@pytest.mark.parametrize('qversion, compiled, version, exact, expected', [
+@pytest.mark.parametrize(['qversion', 'compiled', 'pyqt', 'version', 'exact',
+                          'expected'], [
     # equal versions
-    ('5.4.0', None, '5.4.0', False, True),
+    ('5.4.0', None, None, '5.4.0', False, True),
-    ('5.4.0', None, '5.4.0', True, True),  # exact=True
+    ('5.4.0', None, None, '5.4.0', True, True),  # exact=True
-    ('5.4.0', None, '5.4', True, True),  # without trailing 0
+    ('5.4.0', None, None, '5.4', True, True),  # without trailing 0
     # newer version installed
-    ('5.4.1', None, '5.4', False, True),
+    ('5.4.1', None, None, '5.4', False, True),
-    ('5.4.1', None, '5.4', True, False),  # exact=True
+    ('5.4.1', None, None, '5.4', True, False),  # exact=True
     # older version installed
-    ('5.3.2', None, '5.4', False, False),
+    ('5.3.2', None, None, '5.4', False, False),
-    ('5.3.0', None, '5.3.2', False, False),
+    ('5.3.0', None, None, '5.3.2', False, False),
-    ('5.3.0', None, '5.3.2', True, False),  # exact=True
+    ('5.3.0', None, None, '5.3.2', True, False),  # exact=True
-    # strict
+    # compiled=True
-    ('5.4.0', '5.3.0', '5.4.0', False, False),
+    # new Qt runtime, but compiled against older version
-    ('5.4.0', '5.4.0', '5.4.0', False, True),
+    ('5.4.0', '5.3.0', '5.4.0', '5.4.0', False, False),
-    # strict and exact=True
+    # new Qt runtime, compiled against new version, but old PyQt
-    ('5.4.0', '5.5.0', '5.4.0', True, False),
+    ('5.4.0', '5.4.0', '5.3.0', '5.4.0', False, False),
-    ('5.5.0', '5.4.0', '5.4.0', True, False),
+    # all up-to-date
-    ('5.4.0', '5.4.0', '5.4.0', True, True),
+    ('5.4.0', '5.4.0', '5.4.0', '5.4.0', False, True),
 ])
-def test_version_check(monkeypatch, qversion, compiled, version, exact,
+def test_version_check(monkeypatch, qversion, compiled, pyqt, version, exact,
                        expected):
     """Test for version_check().
 
     Args:
         monkeypatch: The pytest monkeypatch fixture.
         qversion: The version to set as fake qVersion().
-        compiled: The value for QT_VERSION_STR (set strict=True)
+        compiled: The value for QT_VERSION_STR (set compiled=False)
+        pyqt: The value for PYQT_VERSION_STR (set compiled=False)
         version: The version to compare with.
         exact: Use exact comparing (==)
         expected: The expected result.
@@ -74,6 +76,7 @@ def test_version_check(monkeypatch, qversion, compiled, version, exact,
     monkeypatch.setattr(qtutils, 'qVersion', lambda: qversion)
     if compiled is not None:
         monkeypatch.setattr(qtutils, 'QT_VERSION_STR', compiled)
+        monkeypatch.setattr(qtutils, 'PYQT_VERSION_STR', pyqt)
         compiled_arg = True
     else:
         compiled_arg = False